The First Cock You Saw Smaller than Yours

[smokeylink]

Looks like most answers are referencing only adult penises. I gave an answer earlier but I was referring to a time when I was in late puberty and saw a smaller one on a pre-pubescent friend of mine. I'm not sure that I've ever seen a smaller one on another adult. I was once in the showers of a nearby racquetball facility when I saw a guy who looked smaller. In all likelihood, his was bigger than mine but he was very fat and his dick was retracted so far inside his body that you could hardly see it. I'm sure that doesn't count but it is the only time I can think of that I ever saw one that appeared smaller.

[Guest]

You see all kinds of sizes in water polo and the guys locker 

[palmer77]

55 minutes ago, St8joey97 said:

You see all kinds of sizes in water polo and the guys locker 

Dude!  I used to play water polo as well & swimming.  Our locker room was just for the swimmers so it was a lot smaller and separate than the other locker rooms.  Yes--we all saw a lot of each other!!

[IndyBanker1946]

Ahhh...I remember it well.  Three of us kids were playing "doctor" in the backyard.  I was eight, Doug was 6 and Leanne was 8. I showed mine first then Leanne then Doug.  I have no recollection of actually size other than being comparatively bigger than Doug...but he was two years younger.  Leanne did touch me which I teased her about all the way through high school.

[Tim.girourd]

My first long term boyfriend when I was 21, he was 25 .. we had dated for about a month before doing anything sexual, aside from kissing and touching. I was nervous for the first time we’d eventually get physical and see each other naked. I was worried that he’d think I had a small dick .. the first time we had sex we were making out in his kitchen, and started getting real grabby with each other and feeling one another get hard .. we were both so turned on .. and he finally said “you can’t keep kissing me like this and not put out!” So we went to his bedroom, and he said immediately “just so you know, my cock is pretty small” and I was very relieved to think I didn’t have to be worried. When our pants and underwear came off I saw that he was hard and no bigger than 4 inches fully erect at most .. and quite frankly he was so cute and handsome that I found his entire body and cock to be so sexy .. that was the first time I saw a fully erect penis that was smaller than my own. 

[Guest smalltor]

Only guy I ever met that was smaller than me, was a hookup from the gay.com days of long past.  Probably about 2.5" uncut and really thin.  I actually liked it, since it was so easy to suck on.  Always remember him fondly, since the only way he could cum was if you played with his nipples.  Really and truly, if you played with his nipples and nothing else, he would start to cum handsfree in a couple of minutes. 

[SloStroker]

When I was a kid I hit puberty about 10yo. My cock grew sooner than my friends and I was bigger than all of them, but mind you, still very small. That all changed in my teen years. I remember being 17yo and seeing the 12yo boy across the street. He was bigger than me.

It wasn't until I was in my late 20's that I finally saw an adult penis smaller than mine in person. He was about 3" hard and I felt so manly around him.

[sf55]

Admittedly not a huge sample size here for a Kinsey-6 gold-star gay man in his mid forties (I can count my IRL erect penises on one hand, but in my defense, I've been with my husband for over 20 years, since I was 24), but I've only seen one smaller than mine. And I married him.

On our third date, after making out for a while on his sofa, he suggested we move to the bed to be more comfortable. He had a small studio apartment appropriate for a 23 year old, so that was just a few feet away. But as I sat down on the bed, ready to make out some more, he said his rule was no outside clothes in bed, so we needed to take off our shirts and jeans.  When I took my jeans off, he said "oops!" when he saw the wet spot from my pre-cum, but I assured him that I hadn't already ejaculated. I was wearing turquoise boxer briefs, so my size wasn't fully apparent to him.  But when he pulled down his cargo pants (don't judge -- it was 2000), he had the cutest and skimpiest little yellow no-fly briefs on that left nothing to the imagination.  And his cute not-quite-five-inch penis was pointing straight up. And that by itself almost made me cum. But then we did get under the comforter because it was November, and he had a drafty apartment, and we kept making out and having a bit of underpants-on frottage, me on top. 

When he suggested we finally get naked, he was lying on the bed, and I pulled his briefs down, and his cute uncircumcised penis (my first) slapped his tummy.  Then I, on my knees, pulled my boxer briefs down, showing him my own not-quite-5.5 inch circumcised penis (his first) pointing up at the ceiling as it did 20 years ago, and then pulled the covers back over us and resumed the frottage. BTW, its my (limited) experience that frot works best for similarly sized guys who are super hard, which tends to be easier for us smaller guys. He ended up cumming just from the frot, but I had to lie down and let him give me a hand job before I could cum.

Only as we were cleaning up and getting dressed did we finally see each others' penises soft, and since I'm a grower, and he's a shower, he actually looked bigger.  Also, I'm a 5ft 9in heavy white guy, and he's a 5ft 6in trim Asian guy, so proportionally I almost always look smaller.  Only when we're frotting is it clear that my penis is half an inch longer and an inch bigger in circumference. The rest of the time, it's him teasing me for being small.

[cwben84]

I've only met two guys who were smaller than me. The first one was an acquaintance I was chatting online with and I don't remember how but we found out that we were both bi-curious. We were timid about the subject at first but we eventually started to share what turned us on. I told him that smaller dicks turn me on to see if I can gauge how he felt about small cocks. When he agreed and said he preferred small ones too, I dropped a few hints and eventually admitted that I had a small dick. To my surprise he said he was small as well. This got us both excited and after several more naughty chats about what we would like to try with another guy we made plans to meet up to explore our curiosity together.

I invited him to my house one day and went straight to my bedroom where we put on some porn to get us in the mood. It didn't take very long until we were both rubbing our cocks inside our pants at which point I suggested we get naked. We stood in front of each other for a moment looking at our hard cocks. He was about 3.5" long and skinny, about the width of two fingers and uncut. I'm 4.5" cut in case you're wondering. He made the first move by grabbing my dick so I reached for his and started jerking each other. After doing this for a bit I asked if I can give him a blowjob which he gladly accepted and sat on the edge of the bed while I got on my knees. I remember how I liked being able to fit his entire dick in my mouth and that being slim it didn't tire me out as easily.

He then suggested we try 69 so I got on the bed and he climbed on top. He had mentioned that he didn't like the taste of cum so I told him when I was getting close. Then he turned around and straddled my thighs and frotted our cocks together with one hand. It wasn't long until I blew my load on my stomach and on his hands but he didn't stop. Using my cum as lube he continued rubbing us together until he came all over my dick. He laid on top of me and we humped each other gently, our cum mixing together and making squishing noises, our softening cocks trapped in between our bodies.

Finally we came down from our high and took a shower together before he left.
 

Edited January 21, 2022 by RodEnuf
Broke into paragraphs for readability.

[Guest]

The first cock I saw that was smaller than mine was in high school. I don’t remember the size since it was in gym class and all of us had to shower in the open. 

[Mark_1991]

Unfortunately I have never seen anyone smaller than me.Younger male cousins were always bigger and they pointed it out and made fun of me a couple times in from of my dad who is hung very well.My dad stopped it the first couple times but then he just let them do it and told me I needed to deal with it but when I told them to shut up he stopped me and told me don’t get mad at them for telling the truth.

[smallsissyhubby]

Only have seen smaller online, not in person, I am always the smallest. 

[Guest]

Never have seen one smaller than my 3-4 hard inches

[SloStroker]

23 minutes ago, Ncgene2333 said:

Never have seen one smaller than my 3-4 hard inches

You gotta see more men naked. There are a LOT of tiny cocks out there. Some are true micropenises. Us small men aren't rare, just under represented because many of us are ashamed of our dicks. 

[Guest]

I've seen lots of cocks over the years...active since age 12...never one smaller than me...a few close though...I am technically a micropenis...3 and a half hard

[Guest]

My best friend has a micro penis but is completely ok with it, I am completely different as I’m well above average so we have some good banter lol 

[Wookieboy]

On 1/26/2012 at 5:59 PM, RoughPoint said:

In general, do you think guys bond over this stuff?

I made a friend in college who was only 4 1/4 inches and for a time we became besties.   He was Asian, from the Philippines, and told me that in his homeland his penis was closer to average than the men he has encountered in the USA.  Even at home he was subject to much teasing growing up.   We definitely bonded over our smaller size and the kinds of experiences that created in our lives.   He was the first guy I met who has a small penis, though he still had an inch on me.

[maroon8098]

One guy also sticks out in high school when I was a senior and a freshman suddenly became an unofficial pee buddy at urinals and he was noticably smaller than me. He was also picked on for smaller bod height and skinny size and I heard the stories others would share about teasing him. He was barely 5ft, no more than 130lbs and had high pitched squeaky puberty voice and had poor worn handmedown clothes each day. But whenever we crossed paths in school mens room, hed piss at urinal next to me even if no one else was there and had a full grown bush over a small 2-3 incher and balls over open pants and briefs waistband. He didnt hide it and sometimes would stand for a minute or so before piss stream started. Didnt know what to make of it but subtly felt good he was comfy pissing by me even if he didnt peek much at my slightly bigger one. Looked him up on social media one day and hes left the area and is apparently married with a son, so I had a feel good moment he made it past those awkward bullying years too.

[martinfrom75]

In my case, the first cock smaller than me I have seen was on internet, searching info about micropenis. Honestly, in real life I have never seen a smaller one yet.

[Wookieboy]

I saw a picture of a micropenis on line that was smaller than mine.  In real life I have not met a guy my size or smaller yet.

[littledick724]

@martinfrom75

Same here.

The smallest dick I've seen in real life was about 3.75", far away from my 2.5" NBPEL / 2.9" BPEL (I'm only "borderline" to the micropenis condition).

There are very few guys on the internet who share some vids showing off dicks of my size (one can find lots of pretended "real" micropenis photos, but most of them are "Photoshopped"). I even found 2 or 3 alter ego who looked and probably were a little smaller than me, but you are the first member of this site to claim less than 2.5"!

Indeed, 2" (bone pressed or not?) is very short, about 3 to 4 standard deviations below the average. Like what, there is always "more" (small, large etc.) than oneself!

I am also keen on exchanging with other micropenis guys by private messages on this central problem that dominates almost all the aspects of our lives (sexual, social, behavioural, practical and even professional) and is so difficult to overcome, but I don't cam.

Nick

[maroon8098]

One of the other first times took place when I was a HS freshman and went to mens room urinals afterschool and there was a slightly shorter fit sophomore at urinals when I walked to the one next to him. He was blonde, white and a popular athlete who appeared nervous when I stepped next to him. My curiousity took over and I glanced over to see a flaccid 2 incher or so cut cock pissing which was slightly smaller than what I had. He kept looking other way and left fast after pissing. Guess the awkwardness and uncomfortable feeling of what he had took over so he left fast. That was a first introduction to me knowing guys, no matter their social standing, can be smaller than others in less visible average standings like I had those years.

[tomishere]

Over the past 53 years I have seen a lot of cocks. Out of all of them 2 or 3 were smaller. The smallest was an Asian guy who had a   Micro penis . I was very attracted to him and his  Micro penis

[TinyJock]

On 11/27/2019 at 11:15 PM, TinyJock said:

Since I'm straight, I haven't seen that many erect ones. Only soft. As I said, I've never seen any smaller. . . but I have seen a few about the same size. 

In high school there were two guys with similar size cocks. One was a year behind. He was a really cute blonde guy named Chris. (Like a young Robert Redford.) He had a real good-looking girlfriend named Virginia. She had long, honey-blonde hair. They were always together on campus. She wore his letterman jacket. He had a tiny nubbin like mine. It looked especially vulnerable: pale and pink and nestled in light, blonde pubic hair. 

The other was in the same grade as me, named John. We shared a lot of classes together. He looked like a younger version of the former football player and now manager of the San Francisco 49ers, John Lynch. Naked, he looked like a Greek statue, with a smooth, well-defined torso, but cut. He was hung like me: just the head poking out of pubic hair. His testicles were proportioned like on the statues; mine were much bigger, way out of proportion to my small member. They made it look even smaller.

What's funny was that during our senior year we held the two highest offices in student government: he, president of the student council (each home room sent a member); and I, president of the student body (everyone in school had a vote). Since we had open showers in Phys. Ed., it's likely that a good proportion of the guys in school saw us naked at one time or another. Apparently, our having tiny cocks wasn't held against us. It's humorous to think we were considered BMOC.

I confess: I had a total "man crush" on Chris. He was the best-looking guy I've ever seen. Even though I was a year ahead and a BMOC, I was totally tongue-tied by this young blond god. Just like a school girl. Whenever I think of him, I feel the urgent need to adjust my "Sexual Preference" from "Straight" to something less. . .  

 

I ran into Chris earlier this year. He was in town for the funeral of a mutual friend. Like me, he's now in his mid-thirties and better-looking than ever. We had a good jaw. I was surprised what he'd been up to since high school. He'd majored in forestry and had then gone to work for the National Park Service in various wilderness areas, including four or five years in Alaska. From his description, these seemed somewhat isolated and cut off from people and civilization. I asked if it didn't get lonely out there in the boonies like that but he seemed to like getting away from it all. Ah, wilderness! Of course, I had to deftly pry: didn't this also cut into his sex life a little? He said, yeah, but no great loss, it's the price you pay for the joy of living in nature, etc.. Along those lines, he hadn't seen Virginia since high school and had never married. Hmmm. . . 

Of course, my imagination may have been working overtime, but the picture I developed was of a celibate hermit alone by himself in the wilderness, just he and his trusty hand or something like that. It wasn't the life I'd have imagined for such a godlike creature. Hell, he merely had to call and I'd help him bear those long, cold nights under the midnight sun. (Memo to self: Adjust "Sexual Preference")

At one point, there passed a brief, perhaps revealing little exchange. Most of our conversation had been the typical tittle-tattle people toss back and forth when they bump into each other after many years. I was a little surprised then when, out of the blue, he asked about Frank, a bud of mine in school. Frank was a nice enough guy, but, let's face it, totally unremarkable, so, why, I asked, of all my friends and classmates had Chris inquired about him. As far as I knew, they didn't even know each other. Even I, Frank's closest chum, had nearly forgotten about him. He was totally unremarkable -- well, unremarkable except for one notable attribute: he had easily the biggest cock in school, the legend of the shower room. He once confided to me it was 9.5", but Gayle, his girlfriend, always bawdily bragged it was 10". * I concluded that Chris, a fellow small dick, was just as fascinated by the larger end of the size spectrum as myself. I suppose a fellow must think about something to pass those long, lonely nights in the wilderness, and Frank's 9.5" (or 10") seems better than most. **

 

* A funny story: Once at a party, Gayle took to teasing Frank by periodically loudly stage-whispering across the room, "TEN INCHES!" and everyone would laugh as Frank blushed beet red. After this happened, Maggie, a girl supposedly destined for the convent after graduation, perplexedly asked me why did Gayle keep calling out "TEN INCHES!" like that. I stopped for a second how to explain the significance of Gayle's love call to a future nun of America, when the truth broke across Maggie's and she said, "No need, I know." About this time one of the parents finally decoded Gayle's secret message and went into total melt down. The man must have worked in at one time in cryptography and had even fewer inches than Chris and myself. 

** For those who equate the length of the penis to the duration of marriage, soon after high school Frank married a real cutie named Charlene (whom I had previously dated) and joined the Air Force, and just as Charlene divorced him for a local dentist. Apparently she preferred the dentist's drilling. Frank undoubtedly drilled deeper but the dentist more profitably. 

Edited September 3, 2022 by TinyJock

[TotalThomas]

First time? Taking a shower with my friend Chad when I was 11 or 12 I think. He was a year younger and much smaller. And my brother is much smaller than I am so I guess my whole life off and on when seeing him.